As a part of our 2021 Future of E-Commerce poll, we asked people to predict the future of some of the top retailers in America. They were all part of Internet Retailer’s Top 25 list in 2016 and were publicly traded companies. We asked survey respondents to judge whether or not they thought these companies would outperform the S&P 500. These were the results of the poll:
It’s easy to see and understand why most put their faith into Amazon. At the time of the survey and currently, they are the largest online retailer. They account for ~50% of all U.S. e-commerce sales and 5% of all U.S. retail sales.
Other companies like Walmart, Apple, Home Depot, and Costco have proven strength in brick and mortar retail as well as maintaining a strong online presence. It’s no surprise survey takers were optimistic in their performance. For some companies, there seemed to be little to no hope. Companies like Office Depot, Sears and Macy’s had been failing to compete in both e-commerce and retail stores.
To check in on the progress of these companies, we took the stock price of what the companies opened at in January of 2016 and weighed the percentage of change against their opening price in January of 2019. This was then set against the performance of the S&P 500 to see if companies were over or under-performing.
STOCK PERFORMANCE JAN 2016 - JAN 2019
The baseline starts with the S&P index’s performance. Since 2016, the S&P 500 grew from 2011.71 to 2568.11; an increase of 27.65%. All other companies looking to be considered a winner would have to have matched or beat this growth in their stock price.
Obvious winners were companies people already believed in like Amazon which grew by 166%, Wayfair at 113%, Walmart at 53%, and Apple at 48.5%. While a third of survey respondents were confident in Etsy, I doubt anyone expected a 532% growth in stock price from ~$8 to $53. Perhaps even more surprising were Best Buy and CDW. Less than a tenth of survey takers believed in either of these companies, yet they both posted a rise in stock by 85% and 94%, respectively.
For the losers, most of these companies were obvious to survey takers in 2016, as well. Williams-Sonoma, Office Depot, Macy’s and Sears have all posted losses since. Sears the worst with losing 99% of its stock value. Sears plummeted from $20.07 a share in 2016 to opening up 2019 with a mere 0.17¢.
Other surprising losers being Target and L Brands, the parent company of Victoria’s Secret and Bath and Body Works. Almost a third of survey takers were high on Target, but continued store closures have hurt the store and they posted a loss of 4.6% over the last three years. In the same time, L Brands had fallen by 69.5%. Only a tenth of respondents were up on the company, but few probably knew they would underperform the likes of Office Depot. Recent poor press and social media outrage has only further damaged the company.
Nordstrom, The Gap and Groupon should all be noted as companies not posting losses. They simply did not experience enough growth to outperform the S&P index. Nordstrom experienced a five year low dipping to $36 a share in May of 2018. Since, they’ve been on the recovery and opened 2019 at $49.77. Groupon has never shown significant growth since falling February of 2015. The Gap only grew slightly in 2018, only to come back down entering 2019.
Perhaps noticeable by their absence from the current chart are Staples and HSN. In 2017, Staples was bought out by an investment firm and removed as a publicly traded company. The same year, Liberty Interactive, parent company of QVC, completed the full acquisition and merger of HSN with QVC. I included the data for Liberty Interactive over the three year time period, and they fell 22%.
Now’s your opportunity to let your predictions be heard and take the 2023 Future of E-Commerce of Survey. Tell us where you think retail sales will be in five years and more.
Click the link to take the survey now: https://forms.gle/icJhnZJ3nHBtggT77